“DIRECT IMPACT” ON BUSINESS COSTS
Any increase in minimum qualifying salary will “definitely have a direct impact on business costs”, noted Mr Phua Boon Huat, president of the Singapore Furniture Industries Council (SFIC).
Mr Phua shared that about 29 per cent of SFIC member companies fall under their contract manufacturing membership cluster, and their S Pass to EP ratio is about 4:1.
Under these SFIC companies, S Pass holders tend to hold the roles of site supervisor, project coordinator, onsite installers and are tasked with a general work scope that includes manual material handling and delivery.
EP holders are usually hired to become draftsmen, 3D visualisers, project managers or handle business development roles.
“The EP and S Pass holders are part of the overall workforce that contributes complementary skill sets alongside with our local employees. Generally, the foreign workers are tasked to manage more manual labour jobs that they also excel in, and that most Singaporeans shun,” he said.
“EP and S Pass permits enable companies to plug skills gaps and labour supply shortages through foreign talent.”
But the EP and S Pass permit approval process “has not been smooth” for many member companies, adding to their existing woes, added Mr Phua.
“The contract manufacturing cluster members are facing multiple challenges and these include the ongoing manpower crunch and increasing supply chain costs. Companies are faced with eroding margins due to higher costs, making many projects untenable,” he said.
“At the same time, there are pressures from clients to expedite project delivery time as they are racing against time to leverage their rent-free validity period, and are no longer as empathetic as before about manpower crunch issues.”
For food and beverage (F&B) businesses, the adjustment to manpower costs would trickle down to affect customers, suggested Cedric Tang, a third-generation owner of Ka Soh & Swee Kee Restaurants.
“At the end of the day, the cost is going down to the consumers. Yes, we can hire Singaporeans, yes we can pay more for the (S Pass) levy, but who’s going to foot the bill? The companies are not going to absorb all the cost increase,” he said.
“It’s not that business is bad; business is okay. But you have to hire the manpower to keep moving forward and to recover. We have faced two years of losses and now it's a recovery period.”
Mr Tang added that Singaporeans might not realise the levy, in addition to the raise in minimum qualifying salaries for S Pass holders, also hurts F&B businesses.
“And that’s the cost that will ultimately trickle down to the consumers. Everyone loses, but the consumer is the one that loses more,” he said.
To better manage the flow of S Pass holders, the Tier 1 monthly levy will be progressively raised from the current S$330 to S$650 by 2025, according to Budget announcements.
This will affect employers whose S Pass holders account for up to 10 per cent of their total workforce. Those with a higher proportion of S Pass holders are already paying a monthly levy of S$650.
Barring the adjustment to EP and S Pass holders’ minimum qualifying salary, Mr Tang already faces manpower issues. He does not have EP or S Pass holders on his team, but he is open to hiring the latter if he can meet the quota.
“The Government always says that there are Singaporeans to hire, but what I feel they’re not understanding is that in the F&B or maybe service industry, a lot of Singaporeans … are not suited for F&B. Even if we were to hire them, sometimes they leave within six months,” he said.
“If we can hire an S Pass holder, if we have the quota to hire, we will hire. Because foreign workers … they’re more hungry to earn the money. But for Singaporeans, at least based on my experience so far, they want the managerial role or work in (the) backend. But for SMEs (small and medium enterprises), there are limited office jobs for you to have that we can afford.”
POTENTIAL DIFFICULTY IN HIRING, RETAINING WORKERS
Other industries might also need time to adjust to the economic impact of the EP and S Pass minimum qualifying salary adjustments.
The raise in qualifying salaries for EP holders could also be “prohibitive”, and potentially “deter” some companies from relocating expatriate junior professionals, suggested country analyst for Asia under the Economic Intelligence Unit, Yu Liuqing.
“Probably for local companies or multinational companies, if they want to commence their graduate programmes or hire a junior software engineer, this salary can be prohibitive to some,” he said.
“For the (adjustment) applied to the financial service sector as well, such as comparatively lowly paid financial services sector businesses, say auditing, that might be prohibitive too.”
In the financial services sector, where the salaries are higher, the minimum qualifying salary for new EP applicants will go up to S$5,500 from the current S$5,000, according to the Budget announcement.
“It’s generally a market-oriented approach, but again, I'd like to raise (the point) that in some sectors there is already an acute domestic talent shortage, and then you raise the threshold wage for EP. That will only make business harder,” added Mr Yu.
Similarly, managing director of recruitment agency Michael Page Singapore, Nilay Khandelwal, told CNA sectors that rely more heavily on these work pass holders would have to “adjust to what comes next”.
For instance, if an existing EP holder is up for pass renewal, the company’s human resources department would need to assess whether these individuals would be able to have their EP permit renewed or be “downgraded” to an S Pass, he said.
Mr Khandelwal added that regardless of the adjustments to EP and S Pass salaries, jobs related to ESG (environmental, social and governance) are the “new trend”.
“It would be difficult to say that companies would be able to do it without talent coming from overseas markets for some of these positions,” he said.